The dos and don’ts of pairing your watch strap to your formalwear
At Royal Ascot this year, Henry Cavill wore a beautiful vintage Longines with morning dress. It was an inspired pairing: distinctive, elegant and considerably more interesting than the obvious modern luxury watch. It was much admired, and rightly so. But one detail jarred with me: the tan leather strap.
We obsess over watches, but give surprisingly little thought to the thing that holds them to our wrist. Yet a strap is hardly an insignificant detail. It covers more of the wrist than the watch itself and, particularly with formal clothes, can make or break not only the watch, but the entire outfit. The right strap can make a relatively modest watch look wonderfully elegant; the wrong one can undermine something very special.
Which brings me back to Cavill. With morning dress, I believe the rule is simple. A discreet watch on a fine black leather strap, perhaps calf or lizard.
King Charles III is a master of morning dress and understands the details particularly well. The starched collar and tightly knotted Ferragamo tie sitting neatly within his vest slips are characteristic of the precision with which he wears it. His watches never appear to fight with his clothes for attention at Royal Ascot. Small, elegant and discreet, they look entirely at home.


There is, of course, room for a little knowing deviation. My style prediction for next year is the return of the grey top hat, and with it comes an opportunity. A beautiful vintage silver watch on a fine grey suede strap would be an elegant little play on the grey gloves traditionally worn with morning dress. It breaks a rule, certainly, but does so by referring to another one.
White tie is different. Convention suggests that a gentleman shouldn’t wear a wristwatch at all, but I’m not entirely convinced. A pocket watch means a chain, and I like my white piqué vests properly starched and unencumbered. Instead, I would treat the watch as part of the jewellery. Your dress studs, cufflinks and, if worn, vest studs should harmonise, and the watch should sit happily alongside them.
I’m increasingly drawn to a very thin vintage Piaget, perhaps platinum, on a fine black, highly polished leather strap. With white tie, thinness, discretion and jewellery-like elegance outrank mechanical virtuosity. And, whispered very quietly in an esteemed watch publication, I wouldn’t even rule out quartz.
White tie is also one of the few occasions when a gentleman can legitimately introduce precious stones. Sapphires or rubies in the studs and cufflinks open up some wonderfully extravagant possibilities for the watch, although restraint remains important. A discreet stone detail that relates to the dress jewellery is quite enough. I would keep the dial white, ivory or perhaps silver-white. A black dial, however handsome the watch, feels too assertive. With white tie, I want the dial to relate to the shirt, not the tailcoat. And that black strap has another purpose: it quietly echoes the highly polished dress pumps.
Black tie is where things become much more nuanced, and anyone Googling “black tie watch” will inevitably encounter the influence of the Ian Fleming-created spy. Unfortunately, James Bond is a terrible person from whom to learn black-tie watch etiquette.
Go back to the beginning. In Dr. No (1962), when Sean Connery introduces himself at the casino as “Bond, James Bond”, beneath his dinner-jacket cuff is a small gold dress watch, generally identified as a Gruen Precision 510. It is thin, discreet and almost disappears into the clothes. In other words, an extremely elegant black-tie watch.
Then things get complicated.



In Goldfinger (1964), Connery famously wears his Rolex Submariner ref. 6538 on that striped nylon strap with an ivory dinner jacket. This does not, however, give the rest of us carte blanche to wear diving watches with black tie. Bond has just emerged from the sea wearing it. If you too have just swum ashore before removing your wetsuit to reveal an immaculate dinner jacket, I’ll allow it.
Roger Moore continued the tradition of wearing watches because they actually did things. His Rolex Submariner in Live and Let Die (1973) contained an electromagnet and a spinning bezel capable of cutting rope. His later Seikos received messages and occasionally helped blow things up. Pierce Brosnan’s Omega Seamaster became similarly useful equipment.
So, I offer a simple decision tree. Are you a secret agent? If the answer is no, perhaps leave the sports watch at home.
A conventional black dinner jacket gives rather more scope with the dial than white tie. A black dial can look superb, while a midnight-blue dial with a midnight-blue dinner jacket can be particularly elegant. Here the dial can relate to the jacket rather than the shirt.
The white dinner jacket deserves slightly different treatment. It is the tropical expression of black tie: less state banquet, more outdoor cocktail party. Bryan Ferry understood this beautifully on the cover of Another Time, Another Place, wearing an ivory dinner jacket with his wonderfully thin gold Boucheron Reflet. It is also one of the few examples of a metal strap with formal dress that I wholeheartedly approve of. The ultimate seventies sophisticate.
This is also where I might start breaking my own rules on straps. If you are wearing a deep red cummerbund, and you should as long as the bow is black, why not a blood-red leather strap? Keep the watch small and elegant and allow the colour to be the flourish. Formality needn’t always mean monochrome.

Then we come to velvet. Now very much back at the forefront of elegant gentlemen’s dressing, it can range from the traditional smoking jacket to the contemporary cocktail jacket, and this is where you can really have fun. Colour, unusual shapes, complications and obscure pieces suddenly make sense.
If you are entertaining at home, perhaps having a cigar with friends after dinner, you are also in the safest possible environment, sartorially and literally. This is the moment for something extraordinary such as an A. Lange & Söhne Cabaret Tourbillon: complicated, architectural, unusual and just eccentric enough. That wonderful watch you love but can never quite find an occasion to wear? This is it. Get your best watch out of the safe.
Finally, there is “cocktail”, that lovely modern hybrid of black tie and dressed-up evening elegance. If you are wearing a baby-blue, smoky-grey or richly coloured velvet dinner jacket, why shouldn’t the watch join in? A beautiful exotic-leather strap in an unexpected colour can become part of the composition rather than simply something holding the watch to your wrist. Match it, echo something elsewhere or deliberately contrast it, but make the choice considered. The point isn’t novelty for its own sake. Like the clothes, the watch should look dressed with purpose and elegance.
For cocktail dressing, the strap can become part of the fun. Lee at Rushton Leather in Market Harborough makes bespoke watch straps in some wonderfully unusual exotic leathers, including frog and beaver, with the option of a 22ct gold buckle. One of his specialities is making a strap to complement your bespoke Gaziano & Girling shoes, which rather neatly illustrates the point. It is exactly the sort of detail that can turn a familiar watch into something quite different.
Perhaps we should also stop treating a watch strap as a permanent component of the watch. We change our shoes, ties and other accessories according to the occasion, so why not our straps? A beautiful watch can have several wardrobes of its own.
Watch enthusiasts know everything about movements, references, calibres and provenance, but occasionally seem to forget one rather important detail: how to wear the bloody thing!
