One collector on facing his fears… and heading to an Authorised Dealer

Saturday morning.

I woke up from an eerie dream.

Haunted by story after story whispered across internet message boards, my subconscious whipped up a vivid depiction of the banal horror that is buying a luxury watch from an authorized dealer.

Pacing outside a gilded building, I take deep breaths—building up the courage to walk in and buy a “real” Swiss watch. I know that the key to success is to immediately command the respect, and thus the service, of the salespeople inside. I have no appointment. I don’t need an appointment. I’m a real customer with real American dollars, real enthusiasm, real knowledge, and 100% real confidence.

I walk up the steps, place a commanding hand on the door, and push. Nothing happens. Panicking, I jiggle the door furiously. It’s a pull. I stumble backward, right myself, and try to regain my dignity. I walk in, high-stepping to ensure I don’t trip—looking like a Boy Scout on parade. What remains of my surreal confidence evaporates as the staff watch my vaudevillian entrance, offering only a conspicuous side-eye.

Requesting help and receiving none, I am not deterred. I am here. I will browse until my presence compels someone to speak to me.

A commotion at the door grabs my attention as several wealthy families crowd into the boutique. The staff immediately jump into action, greeting everyone by name, offering drinks, and staring me into a corner.

I can work with this. With the staff occupied, I melt into the background, content to quietly shop.

It is not to be. Every time I approach a display case the watches disappear, materializing before the other customers on a felt-lined platter. Each attempt to grasp the mirage is met with a reproachful look from the staff.

I persist. Hour after hour. Customer after customer. My presence is barely tolerated. Each watch teases me, slipping just out of reach with every step I take towards it. Slowly, each timepiece is snapped up, each customer selecting which watch they will look after for the next generation.

Only after each watch is sold—every display case sitting empty—does a tall, slim woman in a striking pinstripe suit approach me, her platinum-blonde hair framing a self-satisfied smile.

“I’m sorry, darling. Whatever it is you’re looking for, it’s already out.”

The ultimate fear: a gatekeeping salesperson, via Lemony Snicket. (Credit Netflix).

What most unsettled me about this dream was how, upon waking, I just knew it was true.

We’ve all read the forums… okay, maybe not all of us, but we’ve all seen Pretty Woman. We know how you’re treated when you enter a luxury boutique—if not from personal experience, then most definitely from pop culture, the definitive arbiter of truth. There are places where some are welcome and others are not. Why would someone, having already convinced themself they belong among the plebs, think they could ever step into a place like that?

I’ll admit that nightmares about luxury goods may not be a common occurrence, so let me step back a moment and explain myself. After a couple of months of (checks notes) not buying any new watches, all while substantially downsizing my collection, I find myself—quite surprisingly—able to afford one of the higher-end timepieces I’ve always admired. It’s incredible. I’m not quite sure how to handle this situation, so naturally my inclination is to go shopping, and now I can finally go to the big-boy stores that sell real watches! Which unfortunately means I need to actually visit those big-boy stores.

Since I started collecting I’ve suffered from a complex in which I don’t feel like I deserve to enter a luxury watch boutique unless I can afford to buy something within. I know, it’s weird. Now that I’ve finally “earned” the right to step into such a place, I am terrified.

As Saturday morning slipped by, I braced myself. I had to go that day. I needed to overcome this fear and finally set foot in a luxury boutique. I could do this.

I showered, sprayed myself in the finest Eau de Parfum I had available (the same bottle of Ralph Lauren Polo Big Pony #4 I’ve had since high school), and went through my whole closet. Four outfits later, I finally settled on something fitting for the autumnal weather. Well composed but not too formal. Something that wouldn’t reveal how hard I was trying: a simple cable-knit sweater, khaki chinos, and white leather sneakers. But which watch to wear? That was the real question. I’d been enjoying a renewed honeymoon with my blue Kamasu and felt that I would be most authentic wearing that watch. It’s nothing fancy, but it’s mine.

I arrived downtown, my destination one of Utah’s oldest and most storied companies—O.C. Tanner.

Utah’s heritage jeweller and watch store, O.C. Tanner

O.C. Tanner is technically not a jewelry company; rather, they specialize in the very real industry of “employee recognition,” which kind of sounds like a glorified jewelry company.

Now, I come from an O.C. Tanner family. Both my grandfathers only bought my grandmothers O.C. Tanner jewelry. My own father would work and save to buy my mother pieces for very special occasions. Look, it ain’t your corner-store Kay. It’s Utah’s old-money jeweler. It’s where you go when you want your someone special to know what they’re worth.

I stood before the old Hansen Planetarium building, the Beaux-Arts edifice glaring down at me. I exhaled—it was a dream, only a dream! It didn’t mean anything. I could stand tall. I could be brave. I would, at the very least, try.

Holding my breath, I ascended the steps. Was the door a push or a pull? The nightmare flashed through my memory. The door drew near. I pulled. Oh sweet baby cheeses, it’s a pull! The heavy door whooshed open, I stepped into the foyer, a security guard nodded, and I passed into the main floor’s atrium. I was met with a fortuitous omen: immediately, someone from behind a counter addressed me and asked if I needed any help. She even looked me in the eyes! (Which I did my best to return, shocked as I was.) Using my deepest, most confident man voice, I calmly and casually explained my interest in their available Omega and Tudor collections, and asked for some assistance in trying on a few models.

Ol’ Reliable: The Orient Mako Kamasu is Japanese accessibility at its best

Interested as I may have been in some of the other brands they had on display, I dared not push my luck. Baby steps.

The hostess graciously obliged, invited me to begin looking at their displays, and assured me an advisor would be with me shortly.

Arms loose at my sides, definitely not swinging like a couple of summer sausages, I ascended a spiral staircase to the second floor. I began browsing the Omega display before excitedly discovering a Breitling display beside it. A warm voice greeted me, I looked up to meet another smiling woman, we introduced ourselves, and she asked what I would like to see. With her grace bolstering my resolve, I dove in.

Admittedly, first-time jitters did keep me on edge. As I picked up the first watch, my impulse to perform took over.

“Are you a collector, or just looking for a nice watch?” she asked.

“Ah, well.” I cleared my throat. “I’m a collector, but I’ve mostly focused on Japanese—oh, and German!—watches.”

(Reader, I’ve owned one German watch in my life; and it’s a YouTuber collab at that.)

Inspecting an Omega Seamaster 300M, I went to try it on and realized I was still wearing my Kamasu. I awkwardly shimmied it off my wrist, trying—and failing—to hide my $300 Japanese special.

“What are you wearing today?”

“Oh, this?” I balled it up in my hand. “It’s just a little thing I picked up in Japan last year.”

I crammed the Kamasu into my back pocket with a self-conscious shrug.

Saving me from my discomfort, she subtly shifted the conversation while fetching another watch from inside the display. She was kind, curious, and open about her own newness to the watch market, sharing that her experience was primarily in luxury apparel rather than jewelry. (Though she was far more knowledgeable than she let on.) She carried herself with a genuine, humble nature which, frankly, helped me relax.

The subsequent thirty minutes were a delight. We slowly moved from display to display, getting to know each other, settling into easy conversation as I tried on several Omegas, Breitlings, and Tudors.

Where are you from? May I see that Superocean? How long have you worked in luxury? You know, Omega really needs to work on their case designs… this thing is so thick. Are you married? I love Tudor’s T-Fit clasp. How many grandkids do you have? Ooo, is that the monochrome Black Bay? What high school did you go to?

As I adjusted the clasp of the Black Bay, she replied that she had attended East High School. Excited (and perhaps a bit forward), I asked when she graduated—quickly adding that my dad attended East and had served as the student body president.

At the mention of Stu Peterson she lit up.

“You know what, I see it now! You look just like your dad!”

Shocked, I asked her last name and was happily surprised to discover our close connections, only possible in a place as small as Utah. (Turns out she’d saved my uncle from a bout of calamitous indigestion at Lake Powell years ago!)

We caught up over each other’s families while I took a Pelagos 39 on and off and posed in a mirror, flip-flopping between it and a particularly stunning Superocean. In a moment of quiet, I even confided my irrational fear of entering the boutique, which was returned with sweet encouragement. Everyone deserved to feel special, she assured me, regardless of how they looked or what they could afford.

As my shopping came to a close, she pulled out her card and jotted down her personal cell phone number.

“Text me if there are any other models you’d like to see—I’ll let you know when we have them in!”

(I will not share her name publicly, but please do DM if interested. I highly recommend her.)

Saturday afternoon.

I left O.C. Tanner without a watch. (They didn’t have the “Dune White” Ranger in stock, after all.)

Next Time: Tudor’s Ranger in Dune White

Stepping out through the polished entryway, I was enveloped in the warm glow of the afternoon sun. I felt strange—confident—as I descended the sandstone steps. I was Mahana from 1969 film Johnny Lingo, and O.C. Tanner had just shown me I was an eight-cow wife.

With a skip in my step, I clasped my arms behind my back and began strutting up State Street. Bouncing along, my hand hit something hard against my butt. I paused, my hand shooting into my back pocket and finding cold steel. I pulled my Kamasu out into the afternoon light, its sunray dial flashing its disapproval of my antics. I sheepishly snapped the clasp shut and shook out my wrist, the Kamasu relaxing into its natural resting place.

Baby steps.

Originally published via Substack at theanalogledger.substack.com