Can one watch collector’s faith in his Explorer alternatives stand up to first contact with the Rolex icon?

They are small gods—the spirits of places where two ant trails cross, the gods of microclimates down between the grass roots. And most of them stay that way. Because what they lack is belief…

What gods need is belief, and what humans want is gods.

Terry Pratchett, Small Gods

It started for me as it did for many a collector.

One moment I’m on YouTube researching recommendations for a replacement for my 15-year-old Timex Weekender; the next, I’m ten videos deep into why every watch collection needs a field watch AND a diver AND a chronograph AND a dress watch AND a “beater” (which is 100% a real thing and not just an excuse to fill that last slot in my watch box).

Am I a watch collector now? I think I’m a watch collector now.

One week later, with four watches on order and claustrophobia setting in, the algorithm decided it was time. I was ready. Enter the Rolex Explorer—the answer to the rat race of collecting—a distillation of everything that is good in our hobby, a detox, a GOAT. The definitive one-watch collection.

I was unimpressed. A boring black dial? A mismatched collection of batons and Arabic numerals? Nope, not for me. No matter what that Urban Chèvre or Teddy Bear said, it was an awkward, boring watch. Thank you—next!

A year passed, a fair number of watches tried on my wrist, and at last I felt like I was finding my way, forging my own path in collecting and curating my own taste. (Cute, isn’t it?) I’d even picked up my first mechanical watch, an Islander 42mm Mitchell Day-T. 

I gorged myself daily at the buffet of social watch content. I now knew the difference between a co-axial and a Swiss lever escapement, Seiko’s role in the quartz crisis, and who had really produced the first modern dive watch back in 1953. Overconfident and overeager, I marched perilously deeper into my obsession.

The spirit of each new watch whispered its sweet promises in my ear, all vying for my worship—and me, a willing pilgrim in search of a god.

The video that changed it all… The Urban Gentry’s Tristano Jeffrey Miceno on his Rolex Explorer

In February 2024, TGV (who, by that time, had become one of my favourite storytellers in our space) published what would be the first in a definitive two-part series about his own Rolex Explorer—reference 114270. 

That damn video, man! Its aesthetic—the b-roll, the music, the history—alchemized into this endearingly kitschy presentation. A love letter to the watch that had captured his heart. I didn’t get it… but I got it. There was something special about the Explorer, something that elevated it far above its flashier rivals. Its voice rose above the others vying for my attention. A big god had chosen me, and how could I ignore it?

Immediately, Instagram took notice each time I stuttered over images of the Explorer, and (quite insultingly) began showing me ads for a wide array of knockoffs. I mean, the algorithm was right, but no one likes being told by a computer that they’re poor. They did look like good copies, though, and the only viable solution for one as impulsive as me was to select a suitable facsimile.

The winning Instagram ad was a 39mm tropical homage from Baltany; they offered two dial options, so naturally I ordered both. Dissatisfied with the fauxtina, I turned to Steinhart; unfortunately, their case design left much to be desired. New whispers—the spirits of Chinese factory brands—reached my ear, opening up a whole new can of worms and taking quite a bite out of my wallet.

Keep buying, keep crying.

One year. Fourteen watches. Factory “clomages” and microbrand homages. It didn’t matter. Every watch fell flat. None carried the life that flowed out from the Explorer.

All this judged by a man who’d never actually seen one in the flesh.

For me, the Explorer existed purely in myth. I sat at its altar—reading forums and essays, admiring photos and videos, yearning for what was just beyond my reach. I asked myself if the watch could really hold everything I’d given it – but come on, it’s the Explorer. 

The odd thing about my quest is that from the beginning I gave up on the idea of ever owning a real Explorer. The waitlists, used prices, and my own impatience all convinced me it was impossible. Impossible or not, it didn’t stop the Explorer from hungrily monopolizing my worship.

Seventy-three years of storytelling; seventy-three years of imagination; seventy-three years of stacking rocks at the base of its mountain. (Which, as we all know, the Explorer never actually summited.) I thirsted for its essence: the life that decades of myth and culture (and marketing) imbued into the watch, renewed with every wrist shot and adoring word.

Preservation of both my sanity and checkbook necessitated that I find some small gods I could call my own. I stumbled through the horological wilderness, but in time, new voices found me. I began building cairns. Not quite altars, not yet shrines, but tiny towers of joy and time raised to other watches.

The first, my Hanhart Preventor HD12. Advertised as “A German Made Rolex Explorer Killer!” It was, quite obviously, a substitute, but it snapped me out of the replica doom loop that had consumed a year of my life. It was accessibly premium, it hummed with 144 years of brand heritage, and sure, the fact that it came out of a collab with the very YouTuber who had triggered my theophany may have been what sold me.

Quite early into ownership, I recognized a different spirit within the Preventor from that which I imagined lived within the Explorer. The watch was not refined, its design and finish the model of German utility. It never tried for luxury. Neither polished nor soft, it was, both in body and spirit, a tool. It quickly became my “grab the go bags! the world is ending!” watch.

The second was my Seiko SPB155, a watch that may yet save me from myself. I value the name Seiko because it means something to our culture. Carrying more than a century of its own history, its heritage rivals the mightiest of Swiss names; proudly, Seiko has been the watchmaker of the masses. 

If you were storming the Bastille tomorrow, you’d wear a Seiko.

Where the Preventor felt like an out-and-out tool, the SPB155’s finer finishing grabbed my attention. Its spirit, that of the everyman, the “Yama-otoko,” filled me as soon as I opened its box.

My small gods: two watches in coalition against the colossus I helped to raise.

I could build their myth as large as I wanted, and they would stand uncontested in my little world, as long as I sheltered them from the Explorer.

It was a deliberate choice.

At my local collectors group’s monthly breakfast, I asked my buddy why he was selling most of his collection.

“I’m saving for an Explorer,” he said.

“Oh”, thunder rumbled in the distance, “nice! New or used?”

“New. I’ve been on the waitlist for over a year.”

“Oof… Sorry, man.”

“Yeah… I know they have them, but they know I’m not a repeat customer, so I’ve just got to wait them out.”

“Dang… hang tough.”

I could hear it, that familiar voice with an invitation to return to the one true path of enlightenment. An undeniable call to its throne.

~~~

“Belief shifts. People start out believing in the god and end up believing in the structure.”

Terry Pratchett, Small Gods

November 2026

My curiosity finally won out—it was time I answered the Explorer’s call. I had avoided this moment for so long. I risked upsetting the fragile balance I’d found in my two little field watches, and I dreaded the moment when I would inevitably discover that both my gods fell short of the Explorer. I was not excited by the prospect of getting back on that ride, but I had to know. 

It was a pilgrimage. Two boutiques, two days, two-tone and steel. 

Still too nervous to approach the Explorer within the walls of its own temple, I first opted for a grey-market dealer a few blocks south of the AD. Their door buzzed and unlocked with a click; I entered a shiny, whitewashed space vibrating with anticipation. Caustic white light and the smell of Pine-Sol assaulted my senses as I approached a Rolex display. The owner greeted me with a nod as he haggled with a customer in a corner. 

In short order I was discussing my quest with a salesman and was presented with the 124270 and 224270. Reverently, I released the clasp on my Preventor’s bracelet and picked up the 36mm of which I’d long dreamed. It was so… small—dainty, really. I tried on the 40mm. It wasn’t any better; oversized in a way that felt unfinished, like a suit in need of tailoring. As I held up each version next to my Preventor, examining them under the harsh lighting, it dawned on me that I liked my own watch more.

It was all so flat—the watches, the jeweler, the whole experience. One big whoosh. No voices, no visions, not even any energy… nothing! As I returned home I stewed over what I’d failed to experience. Could the thing into which I’d invested so much of my own identity really only be a watch? It was an uncomfortable thought.

There were a couple of problems with the experiment. First, I had not brought my SPB155 with me, and I couldn’t judge fairly without also placing it next to an Explorer. Second, the location—I had played it safe and avoided the AD (where I still wasn’t confident I was wanted, despite all of the Explorer’s beguiling promises). Perhaps its spirit was tied to its temple, among its whispering priests and soft-lit altars? 

I would try again.

The next day I attempted a “casual” drop-in at the AD. I squirmed in a chair for thirty minutes while Rolex’s priests argued over who would give me a few minutes of attention in between their scheduled—and paying—acolytes. The lighting was right, the carpet was padded, and no lingering scent of Pine-Sol burned my nostrils. Everyone kept their voices low, and I sat—waiting. Something was in the air; pressure building. Breaking with ritual, a senior priest took pity on me, clarifying that he had less than five minutes before his next appointment, but that I could try on what was in store if I hurried.

Finally, the Rolex Explorer vs the Hanhart Preventor

He removed a 224270 from the display, followed by the gilt 124273, and laid both before me on a felt-lined tray. I took a deep breath, reflecting on my experience from the day before, and boldly placed my SPB155 down next to the two-tone parody of itself—“don’t gild the lily,” my grandmother always warned. The Explorer sat inert, cold and naked under the light. Still warm from my wrist, my Seiko hummed with self-satisfaction. I couldn’t deny which piece I’d rather take home with me. I smiled, realizing that I could have stopped waiting months ago if I’d let myself.

I had not expected the anti-climax of it all.

Together, my small gods and I stared down the Explorer, and I love them all the more for it. They are mine.

I have given them life—scuffs along the polished bezel of the Seiko from the miles we’ve shared bushwhacking the Bonneville Shoreline, and a small dent in the Hanhart’s HD12 steel from dropping it in a stream mid-photo shoot. We’ve enjoyed the backcountry wilds of my home together—red rocks, Wasatch peaks, and the headwaters of the Colorado.

(I’ll admit that a few of those adventures may have been scripted, but can you blame me? I learned from the best.)

Perhaps one day I’ll animate an Explorer of my own, but for now I sit content with my two little field watches. The Explorer’s voice, along with my own doubts, melts into the background—

Wait. Do you hear that? Something’s calling from over on Pelagos mountain…